Your medical cannabis journey simplified: find partnered dispensaries, explore pricing options, earn rewards, and get answers to FAQs, all in one spot.
June 22, 2023 08:00 am ETEstimated Read Time: 5 Minutes
A recent controversial ruling by Florida Judge Dorothy Vaccaro has caught the attention of medical experts and legal scholars. In a surprising decision, the judge ordered a defendant to abstain from using prescribed medical marijuana during probation and suggested using the prescription drug Xanax as an alternative for treating anxiety.
Background of the Case
The case involved a 21-year-old defendant facing a DUI charge in early 2023. During the court proceedings, she informed Judge Vaccaro that she was using medical marijuana to treat her anxiety. The judge responded by stating that anxiety was not a sufficient reason to use medical marijuana and ordered the defendant to stop using cannabis medicinally as part of her probation. Furthermore, Judge Vaccaro suggested that the defendant consider using Xanax to treat her anxiety and visit a primary care physician for a proper prescription.
Xanax, the brand name for alprazolam, is a medication commonly prescribed to treat anxiety. It belongs to the benzodiazepine class of sedatives, which work by slowing down the central nervous system and decreasing brain activity. However, benzodiazepines can cause various side effects, including hallucinations, paranoia, aggression, and depression. Despite these potential side effects, Judge Vaccaro insisted that the defendant stop using medical cannabis and threatened her with arrest without bond if she continued to use it.
Medical Marijuana in Florida
In 2016, Florida passed a law to legalize medical marijuana following a successful initiative that received over 70% approval from voters. The legislation permits physicians to recommend cannabis for treating a range of severe medical conditions, such as epilepsy, PTSD, cancer, and glaucoma, to name a few. Currently, the state Office of Medical Marijuana Use reports that over 800,000 patients in Florida have met the qualifications to utilize medical cannabis for their treatment needs.
Judicial Circuit’s Response
A spokesperson for the 6th Judicial Circuit, Stephen Thompson, explained that Judge Vaccaro’s intention was simply to present the defendant with other options besides medical marijuana. Thompson pointed out that anxiety does not fall under the list of qualifying conditions for medical cannabis use in Florida. Additionally, he mentioned that it is not uncommon for judges within the 6th Circuit to mandate that defendants avoid using medicinal cannabis during their probation period.
Expert Opinions on the Judge’s Order
Peter Grinspoon, Physician, and Author
Peter Grinspoon, a physician and instructor at Harvard Medical School, criticized the judge’s intervention in the defendant’s medical treatment. He stated that it is “presumptuous, inappropriate, and dangerous” for a judge to make medical decisions in such cases. Grinspoon also pointed out that medical cannabis is generally considered safer than Xanax, with milder side effects and less likelihood of addiction.
Jaggers Keene, Primary Care Physician
Dr. Jaggers Keene, a primary care physician in Largo, Florida, highlighted the potential dangers of Xanax’s side effects, including seizures and thoughts of suicide. He also noted that Xanax combined with alcohol could be fatal, a particularly concerning fact considering this defendant was in court on a drunk driving charge.
See If You Qualify For Medical Marijuana -Select Your State!
Legal Scholars’ Concerns
Bob Jarvis, professor of law at Nova Southeastern University, argued that Judge Vaccaro had erroneously based her decision on the defendant’s age, as Florida’s judicial canons prohibit discrimination for any reason, including age. Charles Geyh, a professor at Indiana University Bloomington’s Maurer School of Law, expressed concern that the judge “trumped the judgment of a physician without gathering all the facts.” Geyh emphasized that judges have a duty to make rulings based on provable facts and not personal preferences.
Expanding Qualifying Conditions: The Need for Greater Inclusivity in Florida’s MMJ Laws
Individuals struggling with conditions not recognized by the state may feel compelled to be less than forthcoming about their actual medical needs, fearing that they might be denied access to potentially beneficial treatment. This situation could lead to inadequate care and even exacerbate existing health issues.
By broadening the list of qualifying conditions, Florida could offer a more compassionate and inclusive approach to medical marijuana. That way, patients in genuine need of relief can access appropriate treatment options without fear of being turned away or discriminated against. This expansion would foster trust between patients and healthcare providers and contribute to a more effective and comprehensive healthcare system.
Key Takeaways
The case involving Judge Vaccaro’s controversial decision highlights the importance of dispelling myths and misconceptions about cannabis use, particularly in medicinal treatment. Despite the increasing number of states legalizing medical marijuana and the growing body of research supporting its therapeutic benefits, a lingering stigma surrounds its use. This stigmatization can lead to uninformed decisions, as demonstrated by the judge’s ruling, which ultimately impacts patients who rely on cannabis for their well-being.
As awareness grows, it is essential to challenge outdated perceptions and ensure that individuals who could benefit from medical marijuana will not be denied access to a potentially life-changing treatment due to unfounded prejudices.
Note: The content on this page is for informational purposes only and is not intended to be professional medical advice. Do not attempt to self-diagnose or prescribe treatment based on the information provided. Always consult a physician before making any decision on the treatment of a medical condition.
Lemetria Whitehurst is a cannabis nurse educator and writer specializing in cannabis science and culture. Her career in the medical industry spans more than two decades where she began her career as a pharmacy technician before becoming a registered nurse. As an avid reader
and researcher, she is passionate about educating others about cannabis’ medicinal properties.
Have you ever consumed cannabis and gotten a little too high for your liking? Or have you ever needed to calm down a friend who consumed too much weed for their tolerance level? If so, we’ve got you covered. Although an overdose (taking more than what is medically recommended) of delta-9 tetrahydrocannabinol (THC) is not…
Cannabis tinctures are relatively new on the scene compared to the long, thousands-year-old history of the cannabis plant itself. It was first recognized for its medicinal use in European medicine in 1839, and by 1851, medicinal cannabis tinctures had made their way into a drug almanac known as the United States Pharmacopeia. Despite prohibition throughout…
When Piper Lindeen’s son Zach began showing medical issues at just three years old, no one suspected a rare, severe form of epilepsy. Doctors initially didn’t recognize his symptoms as seizures. Eventually, they diagnosed Zach with epilepsy—but by then, his condition had worsened from a few seizures a week to several each day. As it…
Cannabis access has expanded significantly in recent decades. Many states with medical programs have recently adopted recreational legislation allowing anyone 21 years and older to access the plant. This expanded access may leave you wondering if you should bother getting a medical card when you can just purchase cannabis from a recreational store. Medical and…
Though it may not be as widely discussed as other major health concerns like heart disease or cancer, liver disease is a common health condition that affects millions of people. According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), there are currently 4.5 million adults who have been diagnosed with liver disease living in…
The statements made regarding cannabis products on this website have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration (FDA). Cannabis is not an FDA-approved substance and is still illegal under federal law. The information provided on this website is intended for educational purposes only and is not intended to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any disease. It is not intended as medical advice and should not be considered as a substitute for advice from a healthcare professional. We strongly recommend that you consult with a physician or other qualified healthcare provider before using any cannabis products. The use of any information provided on this website is solely at your own risk.